If you have private student loans and already filed bankruptcy, you may have assumed the chance to address those loans ended with your case. It may be worth taking another look. The Ninth Circuit is now considering Nichols v. Pearson (In re Pearson), a case that could shape how mixed-purpose private student loans are treated in federal courts across California, including San Diego County.

There is no Ninth Circuit decision yet, and no one can promise how the appeal will come out. This is a reason to review your records, not a reason to assume your loan can be discharged.

Why could the Ninth Circuit appeal matter to you in San Diego County?

The appeal concerns whether a private student loan used for both qualifying and nonqualifying expenses can be divided into separate portions for bankruptcy purposes. Because a Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals decision generally controls federal courts in California, its ruling could affirm, narrow, or reverse the approach adopted by the Ninth Circuit Bankruptcy Appellate Panel (BAP).

That distinction may matter even if you were not a party to Pearson. If you are a borrower in San Diego County with a private loan that covered a mix of educational and other costs, the Ninth Circuit’s decision could affect the legal framework applied to your situation.

This post follows the Law Office of Andrew H. Griffin, III, APC’s April 2026 overview of the BAP’s Pearson ruling. The key update is that the dispute has moved to the Ninth Circuit.

What is the appeal asking the Ninth Circuit to decide?

The case is Nichols v. Pearson (In re Pearson), Ninth Circuit Nos. 26-1962 and 26-1963. Pearson borrowed $331,500 from his then parents-in-law, Robert and Cora Nichols, to support his education. The bankruptcy court found that $266,876.81 represented qualified medical-school expenses and held that portion nondischargeable; the remaining amount was dischargeable.

In February 2026, the BAP reversed. It reasoned that the relevant bankruptcy provision, 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(8)(B), covers a “qualified education loan,” defined in Internal Revenue Code § 221(d)(1) as indebtedness incurred “solely to pay qualified higher education expenses.” Because the loan financed both qualifying and nonqualifying expenses, the BAP concluded it did not meet that definition as a whole, and could not be split into dischargeable and nondischargeable pieces. You can read the BAP’s published opinion.

The Nichols appealed, arguing that the entire loan should be nondischargeable because its purpose was to finance medical education. On August 17, 2026, the National Consumer Bankruptcy Rights Center, the National Association of Consumer Bankruptcy Attorneys, and the National Consumer Law Center filed an amicus brief urging affirmance. Among other arguments, the groups say that allowing lenders to trace only qualifying portions would undermine the word “solely” and reduce the incentive to ensure that loans are limited to eligible expenses. Their brief also raises an issue about a year of study at Northumbria University in England through a program associated with St. George’s University School of Medicine: the amici argue that the program was not Title IV-eligible, even though the institution was. Read the amicus brief and its summary.

Treasury regulations also address mixed-use education loans, stating that a single loan used partly for qualified education expenses and partly for another purpose is not a qualified education loan. The Ninth Circuit will decide how the relevant law applies in this appeal; the BAP ruling is not the Ninth Circuit’s final word.

What could the Ninth Circuit decide, and what might each outcome mean?

There are three broad possibilities. Each could affect how lenders and borrowers approach mixed-purpose private loans:

  • The court affirms the BAP. The all-or-nothing approach remains: if a loan does not qualify as a whole, the lender cannot preserve nondischargeability for only the traceable qualifying portion under this provision.
  • The court issues a narrower ruling. It could uphold part of the BAP’s reasoning while allowing lenders to trace qualifying portions in some circumstances, or limit the rule based on the facts or statutory issue before it. The details would matter.
  • The court reverses the BAP. The partial approach used by the bankruptcy court could return: a court might treat qualifying expenses as nondischargeable while treating other portions differently.

A borrower organizing private student loan records, school cost information, and a bankruptcy file

These are possible outcomes, not predictions. As of November 2026, the Ninth Circuit has issued no decision in Nichols v. Pearson, and the timing is uncertain. A borrower’s result would also depend on the loan terms, the expenses paid, the bankruptcy history, and the law ultimately adopted by the court.

Should you review a private student loan that survived your bankruptcy?

A review may be worthwhile if you are a past bankruptcy client or another borrower with a substantial private student loan balance, especially if you were told the loan was automatically nondischargeable. Consider gathering records if your loan may have paid for:

  • Living expenses or other costs beyond qualified higher education expenses;
  • Bar study, licensure preparation, or another program whose eligibility needs closer review;
  • A program that may not have been eligible for Title IV federal aid; or
  • Education costs through a loan from a family member rather than a commercial lender.

The lender’s identity alone does not decide the issue. Pearson involves a loan from family members, but the court still examined whether the debt met the legal definition of a qualified education loan. Likewise, the fact that a loan paid some tuition does not by itself establish that the entire loan qualifies, or that it does not.

Bring the loan agreement, account statements, disbursement history, school cost-of-attendance information, and relevant bankruptcy papers to a review. Records can help show how the loan was structured and where the proceeds went. Treasury’s mixed-use loan regulation is one of the materials that may be relevant to this analysis.

Can you reopen a closed bankruptcy case?

Sometimes a closed bankruptcy case can be reopened, but reopening is not automatic and does not guarantee that a student loan will be discharged. The options depend on how your case was closed, whether the loan was properly listed in the bankruptcy schedules, whether a lender received notice, and whether you or the lender filed an adversary proceeding. A separate lawsuit within the bankruptcy case to determine whether a debt is dischargeable.

A prior judgment or final order also matters. A new appellate ruling does not automatically reopen every completed case or change every past result. Before filing anything, have a bankruptcy attorney review the docket and history of your particular case.

A legal appellate record and brief being reviewed at a desk, representing the pending Ninth Circuit appeal

Are federal student loans treated the same way?

No. Federal student loans are analyzed differently from the private loans at issue in Pearson. Federal loans generally remain subject to the undue-hardship standard in bankruptcy. You should not assume that a rule about a private loan under § 523(a)(8)(B) also applies to your federal loans.

If your balances include both types, identify each loan separately. A review should distinguish federal loans from private loans and evaluate the legal and factual basis for each.

What can you do while the appeal is pending?

You do not need to wait passively, but you should avoid treating a pending case as a guaranteed opportunity. Start by locating your loan documents and bankruptcy records, then make a clear list of which loans are private and which are federal. Note what each loan paid for, which school or program you attended, and whether any court already ruled on dischargeability.

A bankruptcy attorney in El Cajon CA or a bankruptcy lawyer in San Diego CA can review those facts and explain what options, if any, are available under current law. The Law Office of Andrew H. Griffin, III, APC has served San Diego County since 1983. Andrew H. Griffin, III is an experienced bankruptcy attorney, and the firm can help you assess your records without promising a particular outcome.

If you are unsure whether a private student loan survived your bankruptcy, or whether your case may warrant further review, call 619 853-3009, text 619 330-5456, or schedule a free interview at Calendly. You can also contact the firm online. The appeal is unresolved, but a careful review of your own file can help you understand where you stand.